Landmark Commission Minutes - 09/26/2017MIIgUIE5
LANDMARK CuMMISSION
September 2o, z0 -i t
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Staciu Flood, Acting Chairperson ■ I���,s�„
Michele Derr ,
John Dickinson ■
Jim Johnsoi, ■
uindy Ram;rez ,
Michael Smith ■ Council Eiaison
Karn Uagnt .. Planning Aaministratu, ■ City staff
Amy KriRodaii, Municipal Court Prosecutor ■ regal Dept.
ASSENT:
AiOy Cee, Chairperson ■
Barney BruCK ■ P&Z Liaison
uMristy Graham ■
Jackie [el3ow ,
1. Call to order, and Introductions
Acting Cha;rpersu, I Stacie Flood called the meeting to urger at IZ:U5 p.m.
II. Review & Approval -r M;nate5 trum Aagast 22. 2017
Acting Chairperson Flood callus Tur review and approval of minutes from Me A0903t ZZ,
zui t Caiidmai-R Commission meeting. lora. Pli0ele Derr made a motion to approve Inu
miiiate5. Mr. John DicRinson seconaea the mutiun. I He motion was taken to a vote
and pa3sed ananimasly.
11111. Application for Deaiyn Review — 1308 Grant Street ijvvest Flural Fleigfiits) —
Reyaest to remove ane rebu;la emiatiny dCtacFied garage.
Mra. Karen Vagne stated that the applicant vvas prupusing to demoiiSFi and replace Me
nAuting detached yaraye due Lo structural and Tuandatiun i55ae5. I he applicant was
proposing to replaue the garage in kind, with similar materials, Bat was quirly to shift the
location further OauR Trvm the rear alley in order to satisfy current sltl3acR reyairements.
Mr. Randolph Umlah, the applicant, atated the ya, age was uninsurable in its current
state due to the i5sae5 with the foundation. Re Stated the garage itself was bowing in
tM;5 middle and gradually shitting away from tMe Tuncu. ne Stated they had cansiderea
repairing Me Tuandation and maintaining the existing structure, Bat th;5 was not possible
due to the level or termite damage.
I AWDUARK rQUUj4.S_S`lQW pAr.F 2 Sentemher 2F, 2077
Mr. Umlah stated he would be maintaining the existing side windows, some of which
were original -_d enmia that had hmmn rcDlarcd with ple-i-glace. We -fated they Uu=uld
ha m2trh1oa the rGlGrc of the hourze nn the paw garage. He Gt=ted thara had not hasp
goy doom oD thw garage when he purrha--ed the property, but he dirt have pncceccioO
of the original doors. He stated they were baro door style and not wide enough for a
car. He stated the original doors were bowed and he did not have the rack system to
hang the_ no.
Marc, Michele ntzrr asked if the garages was huilt nt the gamP time ac the hnuce, par.
Umlah stated they were constructed at the same time. Mr..lohn Dirkinson asked if
there would be two overhead doors. Mr. Umlah stated there would only be one. Ms.
[!iody Rarnire7 asked if the new r��ctrVrtiCo wC"ld fnllnw the vome nuerha0gc ac the
nrlgionl. Ldr, I Imlah --tnted that' ►Mould he utlll7ing the came n►tarhapgc, but that/ ►unuld
he shortening the rear overhanq from two feet to OOP foot io order to satisfy the cPthark
requirements. He stated they would also he changing the awnings to a rraft_sman style
to match the house.
hdc. Ramira7 asked if the evterinr materialc ware gniag to by the cnMe ac the avletigg
garage, or if they were going to match the houGP. Mr, Umlah -Qtnted they would he
reusing some of the existing materials, but primarily they would he matching the house.
Ms. Ramirez stated she liked the original doors and pointed out they were guite different
frnm the noes hoipg prnpncad, hdr. HMInh stated he had triad tn_ fiod reglar+eMeot dnarc
of a similar style, but had heap unahle tn- lnratea n similar replari=MeUt that rculd
nrrpmmodnte the width of a rnr,
pyre. Mi^hele herr made a motion to appro-e the removal of the existing garage and
replant- with a dater -had garages p]aiotaining ciMilnr etVle and Material.. Ur. Jim
Johncnp cenouded the mnticlo. The r=Gmmiccjoa voted Lila the Motioo; CQQtiQQ pace=d
unnnimalmly.
1u. ADDlic-tion for Design Review - 1701 Buchanan Street [West Floral Heights) -
RegVeat to repair and reQtore evicting fr_nt pnrt!1% =__f in 41^d.
pare, rZagpe stated the property at J 7n j Rurhapap gtreet had hoan fnrerinced n_n and
the applicant, Jonathan Smits, waG propnciog to repair the frnnt porch np hohalf of
Wells Fargo Home Mortgage prior to the resale of the property. She stated n
contractor, Mr. Glen Solomon, had been hired to do the repairs.
Mr, gMitc stated that b4r. Rnlmmnp'c eehedu le ►Arae such that ho would he ahfe tn- da the
work in January, 901 R. IIP Gtnted the hank had agreed to release the pececcary f, Inde
pending the approval of the I nndmnrk Commission. par. Smits stated that in itcz current
shave, the north cover was a safety hazard. He stated Mr. Solomon would he keeping
tMe evicti=g the pillare, but the _otic_ arced roof would need to be replaced.
Mr. Johnson ackPd if the roof was haipg replared using the came typo r►f materialc ac
the existing roof. par. Smits said the rontrartor harf confirmed that he would he ahle to
replace the roof in kind and maintain the original integrity of the stnirture.
Uc. P2Wira7 aclrad if thara wac- any iGtentj=o to add a gutter or ridge in order to mitigate
future_' damage due to water run-off. Ur, nirkincnp D=lot-d _ut that the Dorch was
Lr 190MRK C:UI9iMIbtsion rel GA! 3 5epiarmoal: A, Al I
original to the houba and clearly had lasted a very long time. Re suyyu3ted it Ba pat
back in tMe same man„ar. Mrs. Dei r asted what type of roofing material was going to
be used. Mr. Smits states they vvcald mist IiRely Be acing the same materials that were
on the existiny roof.
Ms. Ginay Ramirez maac a motion to approve the replacement of tMe Tront porcR uo„er
at 1701 Buchanan Street. Mr3. Michaele De, r seconded the motion. The commission
voted on the motion; motion passed unanim„aaly.
v. Application for DeS;yz, Kcvievv - 2908 10t" Street (West Floral Reignts) - ft in rat
to replace existing poor with ti6ergla5s. Graftsman Style door.
Mrs. Gagne states the applicant., Max dna Jan Phipps, recently wem approved for and
completed fvaridation repairs to their Rome, ru-seltin-y in 3EcondaF y issaes openiny and
closing the Mont door. She stated the applicants were propuaing to replace the door
vvitR a navy, ti6ergla55. Grattsman style door.
Mrs. Jan Phipps states they ,,,O -Ula liRaiy yo with a dark or Black stain for the door, rather
than white. She stated they has selected tMe uranumar, style door With the single pane
of leaded glass to go with the style of the house, But were not particular oFi the style of
Me door and would Be flexible if the Commission felt anotRer wouia Be mon:
appropriate.
Mrs. Derr stated the current door on Me Ruaae 'ai'a not appeal to Be oriyinal. Mr.
DicRinson asked if the existing door was solid woos. Mrs. Pnipps stataa She Believed it
vva3 solid wood, Mrs. Gayne' stated the Commission Raa previonalr apprav7=a
Aerglass doors in one 5ituatim in the Depot square Historic District and Rad received
verification Trom the i u.,aa Ri5turical Cup mission ( I HG) that fiberylass was an
acceptable replacement material.
1015. Kai, irez- said that there were varying qualities wRen it came to TiBGryla3a doors aria
Mat it vvas aiTricult to tell trm the pictures what quality the door would Be. Ms. PPiippa
statea tMe auur vvuala Be coming trm Sailders wholesale. Mr. Dickinson stated tRey
carried high quality prodoct3.
Mrs. Michele Derr made a motion to approve tRe door ruplacumant Tor zY08 1 gl" Street.
Mr. Jim Jannson seconded the motion. The commission votea on tie mutiun; motion
pa3sad ai ianimuusly.
A. Other Business:
a) Monthly report: Depot Square Ristor;c uiatr-Ict, Wast Floral Reignts R;storic
136trict_ Morningside Ri5turic District
Mrs. Michele Derr stated the Calle Ocho street festival was coming up on uctuBer
,tn, the Cions Lla6 woala ba haviny their Food Track Challenge on October .i4tl, ana
Me Rater NUara Art vvalK would Be havi, ig their season tinale on October 51^. She
stated Kell Rouse Party on Me i_avv, , vvas coming op on uctoBer 1 yth.
Mr. Jim Johnson stated Sunday, OctoBer -i3t would Be Morninys;ae'5 annual
neighborhood meetiny where it would be decided when to put out lam;nariea. Fla
I ANDMARK f'. MMIRSION PAC -4F 4 I�zeptemh-r 2F, 2017
stated the question of what authority the Landmark Commission has over the
U!2rnlggCide dictnric nic+rict ,u_uhd alc_ be discussed at this meeting.
h) neslgo Review --Staff Authpri7ed—Minor AlterationcLRapnim:
Mrs. Karen Gagne reported there were no staff authori7pd minor alteratinnclrepairc:
,-) Artieleo & Perindi--l-: d=ue
VII. New Business:
a) 4B lananti,..o r-rmnt - pprc. r -g=_ ctoted the Backdoor Theater had submitted
an apglinntiQg fpr fi rndc to repair their parking Int. Cha ackrad if the r===lccion
wpiild nen-,ider the- repairs n staff ndminictrntiva rav1ew, pr if that' xnrgVld
consider it a Commissiaa review. Mr. ,john DirkioGoa stated he heIlPved thlC
should be a staff review. Actina_ Chairperson Flood stated she agreed that it
chn_uld he r-lia-ad KV staff. n_V Ierikn-riao, Legal representative, stated the
came criteria that Ward gegerallV applied regardiug design malic=e chnuld alc=
appy in thiG inGtanr.e. Mre, herr -q#ated qhe didn't cap why the repaving of a
parking lot would be something the Commis-,iou would neer) to rev1ew. hors,
ragn_e stated they would move forward with staff administrative review for the
prgjerrt,
h) Next Mtg. – Tuesday, OntphQr ?d, at 19 pm
ILIII. ArjeZ-r-_:
Meetigg adj=urged nt 1.14 _Dm
�d 2�r1
A_dv I ee. Chairperson Date F