Landmark Commission Minutes - 08/22/2017mllquits
LANDMARK Cu14 M1sa1ula
Aayast 22, 2017
MEMBERS PRESEN i:
Andy Cee. Chairperson
■ Members
Barney 6raCK
. P*L [i..:3or,
MicfRfie Derr
■
Jonn DICKinson
■
ChrisEy Graham
■
Jim Johnson
0
Stacie Floud
E
Vinay Ramiro
s
Michael sillith ■ Council Liakzn
Karen Gagn-, Plana Ing Aaministrator ■ City 518R
lout[ Prouty, Planner II
ABSEN 1:
JacRia CGBow E
1. Call to Order. and Inirudactlun5
Chairperson Andy Cee called the meetiny to order at 12:03 p.m.
li. Ra.iv.. tk Approval ut minute5 tram June 27, 201 t
ClSairperson Lee called Tor review and approval OT rninutGs rrum Me June zr, zUI r
Landmark Commission meeting. Mrs. Michele Derr mase a motion to approve the
minates. Mrs. Christy Graham seconded the motion. The motion was taken to a vote
and passea unanii i i0cisly.
Ill. Application Tor oesiyn Rs.;a.. — 80u UFI;U A,►enae (Zales eu;Riiny) — RatiaeSt to
install new sign, awnings, and outdoor dining rence.
Ghaiiperson Lee recused himself from the case. Vice -Chairperson Christy Graham
asked stmt to present the case.
Mr3. Karn Gagne stataa Out tMe applicant, Ammer ScFiacter, was propobing to install a
new Blade sign Tor Karat Bar F urill at Me corner on tM-W Buildiny locatea at goo O lin
Avenue. She state's the applicant was also proposing to construct nevv avvnings and a
perimeter Wince for the outdoor dining area.
Mr. Andy lea, representative for the applicant, stated that becaase projection siyns IiRCe
tale one Being prupusad vverc not an allowed sign type, the sign would need to 5e
approved Dy tMU ZOMiny guard OT Adjaatment5 Tellevviny approval by the landmark
I AWDUAau cnUUj-gclnd PAGE 2 Amom- 22 2297
Comml-qGlon. Lie gtatpd an eQ,-machmaut agreement with the City would afro ho reguired
for the sign. Mr. I ee stateri him had provided cavarnl examples of signs similar to the nue
heir,g Proposed located throughout the riowutawa area, a_d th-t the owner was willing to
uca tha nriginal 7 -les sign frame for the new sign.
Ms. Cindy Ramirez asked how the eigo wnS being attached. Mr. Sahinn Ganti tpv?n,
design consultant for the projert, stated the eign would be attached and supported using
He stated the sign would also have I Fn lighting.
Couor'ilor .gMith =eked if the lighting would be shining on the sign, or internal to the wig=.
Mr. Santistevan stated tho lighting would he internal to the sign and would plug into the
wall. He stated that marquee lighting would opt he ap_pr=ued because it is not removahle.
Ur. Jahn nickenson explained that the City does nrit wept live a!nrtricity on the exterior
of.a huildiog hecnus- it could pose a potential danger to workers perfnrming utilitV work.
Ms. Cindy Ramirez asked if the new aw=in_u- were going to be anchored to the huiidinq,
or if they were going to he removahle. per. Santiratauan stated the awnings would he
anchored to the building via an internal steel henM.
Mr. Rnrpey Rrprk made the m=tion to approve the proposed Gigonge as greGeoted. Urs.
Michele Derr seronded the motinp. The enm_i-sion voted on the motion; motion passed
unanimously.
Mr. Andv I ee Gtnted that Mrs. Michele Derr had provided several hictQric photos of
awnings in the downtown area, pare, nerr stated the sanhorn maps for the gran antnto
the materials for Mont of the nwoioga-, and that there were currently 9 n huildiogs in the
neoot Sguare district that had awoiogs.
Mcz. Rtarie n'Innd melted if IHC had reviewed the current prnpncal. Ur. I ea stated it had
heen inrluderi in tart R _f the Ognlication to THC for the Interior remodel Of the pr^_party.
Ms. Ramirez asked if the anrhnr points for th= a%AfningQ would be standard or decorative.
Ur. -qan-tictevan explained that the awnings wpirld he aoch=rad by a solid anchor with n
hnpk and that the rod would have the same look as the historir awning.
Mr. Jim Johnson asked if the awoiog-- were only going to he placed on unit A. Ldr-.
-Srhacter stated it they may eventually want to place nwsings on units C & D, but it would
depend Qu what businesses ended up going into thoGA uoFte. She stated she would like
to plata on aufpiGg an unit B, but they were very expensive.
Mr. Lee stated he was working urith the city on a combined enrroarhment agreement fn_r
the awnings and the patio area. dP stated these wnuld provide a positive addition to hath
the huilding and the downtown area.
Mrc, narr asked if tha pati^_ fencing was going to he I or d feet tall. Mrc Crhacter stated
it would he a feet tell, and would he similar to the fence at the Iron dorsa puh. per.
Santistevan stated the patio area ►Mould ha Q feet 4 inches wide and would lea+.e
^_f clearance.
LANIWARR COMMISSirm pgOE 3 A 2417
_. `.—�
Mr. Jim Johnson asked wnen trey planned on moving forward v-itit the project. Mrb.
Surlac;rvr stated they planned on applying Tor 6allaing permits by late vctuftr aT early
Novemoer.
Mi. Barney Brock made a motion to approve the proposed aYvu,inys and patio. Mr. Jim
JoFinson Seconded the motion. I Pie commission voted on the motion, motion pasbed
unanisimosly.
Iv. Discussion and Rct;an Item: E&pans;on of Depot Square National 1916turic District.
nnr5. Uayne pointed to the arUa3 ut potential expansion of tete Depot Syaane National
Fliaturic 06trict. Mrb. Graham stated zMe Mad spoRen with several downtuv„ n ooziness
owners vvnu ware interested in Being incluaea iVI Me eApansiof . W. Flood recomm-Undea
compiling a list ide,-tifyiny the property owners expre3aing iiPterest in Becoming a part or
the district.
Mr.-. Uraham pointed out that the vuu alocR et Scott was currently not contril5at;ng_ bat
there wem several 6aildi, iys in that area that Mad bee, i constructed during the -196u-a and
1970's. -OMe stated it would albuu be good to incluse Me vvii;nita l Heater if there were
williny to participate. lVla. Flood stated these were also a lot of non-co,itr'Butiny Buildings
between 3m and V Streets that could 6e looked at as possiple indiviaaoal laiiamarkb.
V. utMor Basiriess:
a) MontRly wport: uepot Square Historic District, West Floral Heights Ristor;c
District, rvrorninya;du R6toric District
Mrb. Michele Derr stated tMe Food I rack Challenge would 6e Field on Uctober 141",
and the Atte, Rours Art vvalR YYa3 coming up on September r«. SMu ztatca that UB'b
5110p, Me I uu leb Bailding, had sola and the new owner was Jon Reese.
Mr. Jim JoMn3u„ Stated tHc Morninyside annual nuigrlborMood meeting was coming
op in September.
13) Desi-yn Review—Staff Autllori=aa—minor Alto ratio nslRepairs:
mr3. Karen Gagne reported on the seven atart aatHori ced minor alteration3impairz:
- 13vv Zamar•— hUplace HVAC System - Feryveresn. 11Ic.
R
- 2028 Avondale - ep►aee HvAC System- James Layne Fleas►f,g & Ai,
- 7478 Garfield - Replace F7vAC Sy,,lef„ - Gillem Hearing arra A;T Coad.
U) Art;clCs & Periodicals: Tete MuZie ll;on - Summer 2017
X. New Businu,.a:
a) Next Mtg. - r uesday, SeptemBer 26; at 12 pm
Kh. Riji;urn:
IMM—=Iiny adjourned at 1:20 pm
0
Andy Fee, Chairperson Date