Min 07/21/2009 ` 631
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
Wichita Falls, Texas
Memorial Auditorium Building
July 21, 2009
Item 1
The City Council of the City of Wichita Falls, Texas met in regular session on the
above date in the Council Chambers of the Memorial Auditorium Building at 8:30 o'clock
a.m., with the following members present.
Rick Hatcher - Mayor Pro Tern
Glenn Barham - Councilors
Michael Smith -
Jim Ginnings -
Charles Elmore -
Mayor Lanham Lyne - Absent
Dorothy Roberts-Burns - Absent
Darron Leiker - City Manager
Miles Risley - City Attorney
Jessica Wheat - Deputy City Clerk
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher presided over the meeting in the absence of Mayor
Lyne.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher called the meeting to order.
Item 2a
Councilor Jim Ginnings gave the invocation.
Item 2b
Mayor Pro Tem Hatcher led in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Item 3a
Mayor Pro Tern informed that there will not be any presentations.
Mayor Pro Tern expressed his condolences to Councilor Roberts-Burns
and her family in the loss of her sister.
Item 4
Patricia Sutton, P.O. Box 8391, requested that the $394.95 mowing lien placed on
her property on 33`d Street be waived. According to the notice from Legal the lien was placed
on the property September 22, 1972, however she did not own the property at that time. She
inherited the property in 1996 from her Aunt who had lived there since 1976. She wants to
contest the lien and amount owed. She said the City's Sanitary Codes imply different costs
for mowing. She mentioned the Tax Code and asked that Council look at the statute of
limitations. State laws are in effect in this situation and she asked to speak to someone in the
Legal Department to remedy this.
632 '
Item 4 continued
Mayor Pro Tern will look at the information she provided and contact her about the
findings.
Item 5
Minutes of the July 7, 2009 City Council Meeting were approved with one correction.
Item 6
City Manager gave a briefing on the items listed under the Consent Agenda.
Moved by Councilor Barham that the Consent Agenda be approved.
Motion seconded by Councilor Ginnings and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings, and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 6
RESOLUTION NO. 94-2009
Resolution Awarding Bid For The City's Estimated Annual Supply Of
Meter Boxes And Lids To The Marta Company In an estimated amount
of$70,550.00
Item 7a
A public hearing was held on the Proposed FY 2010 Action Plan of the 2005-2009
Consolidated Plan to allocate HOME Investment Partnership Program (HOME) funds in the
amount of$555,120 and Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds in the amount
of$1,400,527 and re-allocate$300,000 in FY 2009 CDBG funds.
Mayor Pro Tern declared the public hearing open.
Mr. Dave Clark, Community Development Director, commented that this final public
hearing is to facilitate citizen comments on the proposed FY 2010 Action Plan of the
Consolidated Plan that is recommended to the Council by the Council Subcommittee on
Outside Agencies as a result of its June 5, 2009 interviews with local non-profit agencies and
City departments. A total of $3,513,615.24 in funding requests was submitted to the
Subcommittee. CDBG funds available for projects totaled $1,700,527. The first public
hearing was held on June 4, 2009.
Mr. Clark informed that the City proposes to use FY 2010 CDBG and HOME
entitlement funding amounts and FY 2009 Reallocated CDBG funding amounts as follows.
CDBG: Non-Profit Agencies $ 334,044
CDBG: City Departments $ 1,366,483
HOME Program $ 555,120
(Totals reflect the amount combined that applicants requested in each area.)
Mr. Clark informed that sidewalk construction assistance along Windthorst Road was
recommended for the Early Head Start Program to be accomplished by the CDBG Concrete
Training Crew.
Mr. Clark read a letter from Mark Masman, Executive Director of Christmas in Action,
Wichita County, TX, Inc. thanking Council for consideration to approve CDBG funding for
Christmas in Action. He also mentioned an area of concern in the additional requirements
that HUD keeps imposing are getting more difficult to complete. But with the help of various
City offices we are able to meet these requirements; just an added cost of our own time and
resources. He would also like to thank the Community Development office, Neighborhood
Resource office, Planning Department, Inspections Department and Property Management
for their help in making Christmas in Action a successful organization.
` 633
Item 7a continued
Mayor Pro Tem called for additional public comments. There being none, Mayor Pro
Tem declared the public hearing closed.
Item 7b
RESOLUTION NO. 95-2009
Resolution Approving The FY 2010 Action Plan Of The 2005-2009
Consolidated Plan Of The City Of Wichita Falls To Allocate FY 2010
HOME Investment Partnership Program (HOME) Funds In The Amount
Of $555,120 and FY 2010 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG)
Funds In The Amount Of $1,400,527, And Re-allocate $300,000 In FY
2009 CDBG Funds
Moved by Councilor Ginnings that Resolution No. 95-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Barham.
Councilor Ginnings asked if a certain amount of Code Enforcement
salaries were allocated in this program. Mr. Clark replied that they were.
Councilor Ginnings asked if we did not have CDBG money that those costs would
have to come entirely through the General Fund. Mr. Clark replied in the
affirmative.
Councilor Ginnings asked if the replacement of failing water lines referred
to were residential connections. Mr. Clark replied in the affirmative and explained
that the areas involved were primarily residential. Councilor Ginnings said that he
wanted to ensure that no trunk lines were involved in the replacements.
Councilor Elmore requested that a sidewalk underneath the 287 bridge on
City View Drive be considered under the Concrete Training Program. This will
help the kids that live at the trailer park get to the grade school and high school.
Mr. Clark said they will take a look at that but it will have to meet the criteria that
serves primarily low to moderate income families. Councilor Elmore commented
that the trailer park in that area is not what you call a high income group.
Councilor Elmore asked if the water facility replacement project is limited
to low income areas. Mr. Clark responded that it is.
Mayor Pro Tem sits on the subcommittee on Outside Agencies and he
commented that they needed $3.5 million to do what was requested and it is hard
to stretch half of that to cover it. We just do the best we can and try to prioritize
what we can do. There is always more need than we can fund for those things.
Mr. Clark thanked Councilors Hatcher, Roberts-Burns, and Smith for
taking the time to answer all those questions the citizens had at the meeting.
Councilor Ginnings commented that cleaning up the deterioration of a
number of years has led us to unofficial discussion of maintenance codes. If you
tend to neglect, ignore, or let things go eventually it leads to deterioration. This is
the reason we have these grants to take care of these things. If we had
maintenance codes to apply we would not have so much catch up to do and there
would not be such disparities between available funds and needs.
Councilor Elmore commented that part of the problem is that we wait too
long after a property has been abandoned. It may still be in reasonable condition
but we wait four, five or six years before we do anything about it; by that time it
has been torn down. I would like to see that some way we can resolve that issue.
Motion carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tem Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
634 '
Item 8a
A public hearing was held concerning the City's application to Texas Parks
&Wildlife Department for a matching grant for improvements in the 80-acre
Wichita Bluff Open Space Site.
Mayor Pro Tern declared the public hearing open.
Mr. Jack Murphy, Director of Parks and Recreation, commented that this
hearing is required by the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department for compliance
with their matching grant application guidelines. This public hearing will allow for
citizen comment on the proposed grant application.
Lana Parker, 1505 Ridgemont Drive, expressed concern with the proximity
of this area to the houses and how they back up to some of the houses. Her
concerns included the possibility of higher crime rate, more fires, ruining the
wildlife habitat, and the maintenance. We are afraid for the safety of the residents
there and for our wildlife there. We would have to put up fences to keep people
off our property, but then we would not have the wildlife coming into our yards
anymore. One of the reasons we are there is because of the wildlife and I was
curious as how that is going to be approached in the plan.
Mayor Pro Tern explained that the general idea is to keep that area as
natural as possible and not disturb any of it other than putting the ten foot
concrete path through there.
Mr. Murphy commented that there is actually a significant width between
the private property and the property bought by the City. The primary goal to
acquiring the property was to preserve the open space, wildlife, variety of
vegetation, and bluffs on the property. As to the fire hazard in that area, what you
see now is what you will continue to see in that area. It is grass but it is like any
other area in that location. As far as crime is concerned, our experience with
trails has been entirely positive since we started putting trails in twenty years ago.
The more citizens were on the trails the crime was reported, if there was crime,
and that has been an asset for the trails. It slowed any criminal activity in those
areas, if it arose. We invite all citizens to participate if they have any ideas on
how to lay the trail out.
Councilor Elmore asked if they were going to allow dirt bikes on the trails.
Mr. Murphy explained that regular bicycles or dirt bikes are allowed but not
motorized bikes.
Mayor Pro Tem called for additional public comments. There being none, Mayor Pro
Tern declared the public hearing closed.
Item 8b
RESOLUTION NO. 96-2009
Resolution Designating Certain Officials As Being Responsible For, Acting
For, And On Behalf Of The City Of Wichita Falls ("Applicant") In Dealing With
The Texas Parks & Wildlife Department ("Department") For Participating In
The Local Park Grant Program ("Program"); Certifying That Applicant Is
Eligible To Receive Program Assistance; Certifying That Applicant's Matching
Share Is Readily Available; Dedicating The Proposed Site For Permanent
Public Park And Recreational Uses; And Certifying That The Application Has
Been Submitted To The Appropriate Regional Council Of Governments For
The Texas Review And Comment System (TRACS) Review
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Resolution No. 96-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Smith and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
635
Item 9a
ORDINANCE NO. 44-2009
ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF WICHITA
FALLS, TEXAS, ("CITY") APPROVING A NEGOTIATED RESOLUTION
BETWEEN THE ATMOS CITIES STEERING COMMITTEE ("ACSC" OR
"STEERING COMMITTEE") AND ATMOS ENERGY CORP., MID-TEX
DIVISION ("ATMOS MID-TEX" OR "COMPANY") REGARDING THE
COMPANY'S RATE REVIEW MECHANISM FILING IN ALL CITIES
EXERCISING ORIGINAL JURISDICTION; DECLARING EXISTING
RATES TO BE UNREASONABLE; REQUIRING THE COMPANY TO
REIMBURSE CITIES' REASONABLE RATEMAKING EXPENSES;
ADOPTING TARIFFS THAT REFLECT RATE ADJUSTMENTS
CONSISTENT WITH THE NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT AND FINDING
THE RATES TO BE SET BY THE ATTACHED TARIFFS TO BE JUST
AND REASONABLE; APPROVING ATMOS' PROOF OF REVENUES;
ADOPTING A SAVINGS CLAUSE; DETERMINING THAT THIS
ORDINANCE WAS PASSED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
REQUIREMENTS OF THE TEXAS OPEN MEETINGS ACT;
DECLARING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND REQUIRING DELIVERY OF
THIS ORDINANCE TO THE COMPANY AND THE STEERING
COMMITTEE'S LEGAL COUNSEL
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Ordinance No. 44-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Barham.
Councilor Ginnings asked if there was a staff presentation. City Attorney,
pointed out that on March 6, 2009 Atmos filed an application to increase natural
gas rates seeking a $20.2 million increase. The Atmos Cities Steering Committee
has negotiated a reduction in that. What is presented today for your approval will
cut that $20.2 million tariff increase to a $2.6 million increase effective August 1,
2009.
Councilor Ginnings asked why the wide disparity between the request and
the settlement. City Attorney stated that it is actually not that wide of a disparity
when you consider that it is in the margins of tariffs that total hundreds of millions
of dollars. Actually, when they first made the request of approximately a $20
million increase we were requesting approximately a $20 million decrease. So it
worked out about halfway between the increase and the decrease.
Councilor Ginnings asked if Atmos Energy is still trying to fill a hole that
took place along with or maybe prior to the run of the prices.
Randy West, Atmos Energy, 1602 Jefferson, Bowie, TX, informed that this
does not have anything to do with the cost of natural gas. This is the delivery
portion of the natural gas, so as the prices go up and down with the natural gas
market it gets passed on to our customers. Right now customers are enjoying the
benefits of our lower gas prices. There is a $9 million recovery over this particular
increase and that is why it looks a little different. When they balanced last year's
over recovery into it that is when it brought it down to $2.7 million. It will only be
on a 4.7/MCF average customer billing which is a 15 cent increase per customer.
The revenue mechanisms work really well with the Steering Committee and the
negotiations made.
Councilor Ginnings asked that given these are not related to the price of
gas, there is a schedule in the contract proposal that states the price of gas.
Residential prices shown in here are 2.27/MCF which is really below market value
so why is it in here? Mr. West explained that it is the delivery cost and the actual
cost is including the gas recovery cost (GRC).
Motion carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
636 '
Item 9b
ORDINANCE NO. 45-2009
Ordinance Amending Section 6.4 Of Appendix A Of The Wichita Falls
Code Of Ordinances To Modify Regulation Of Oil And Gas Wells
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Ordinance No. 45-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Smith.
City Attorney informed that earlier this year some City Council members
wanted to find a way to speed up the process of permitting oil and gas wells in the
City but yet retain the protection afforded to the citizens of the City. Staff and two
Council members who are involved in the oil business put together an ordinance
that provides those protections but also eliminates the conditional use process,
that before this tended to create delays in getting approvals for oil and gas wells.
There is quite a bit more regulation within the ordinance itself but that regulation
substitutes for the conditional use process that was previously placing regulation
on a case by case basis.
Councilor Ginnings asked for clarification on page two of ten about
permits. Is the permit the initial permit and also the permit referred to
subsequently, they are not additional permits. City Attorney replied that he was
correct. Councilor Ginnings commented about page four of ten, it appears that
we are requiring well control insurance for the life of the well.
Councilor Ginnings asked if after the well is completed and is producing
oil and the drilling operations since then passed, we have to carry this insurance.
City Attorney responded that the desire is to obtain the insurance at the most
highest likelihood of danger from the well which is when it is initially drilled. We
do not have a mechanism to monitor wells throughout their life span which might
be decades and maintain that insurance continuously kept on file. That would be
substantially more expense.
Motion carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 9c
ORDINANCE NO. 46-2009
Ordinance Appropriating $9,433 To The Special Revenue Fund For The
Immunization Program Of The Wichita Falls-Wichita County Public Health
District
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Ordinance No. 46-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Barham and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 10a
RESOLUTION NO. 97-2009
Resolution Directing Closure Of A Railroad Crossing At Granger Street,
Subject to Burlington-Northern Santa Fe's Installation Of A New Railroad
Crossing At A Kell Boulevard Service Drive Between Fairway And Barnett
Roads
Moved by Councilor Barham that Resolution No. 97-2009 be passed.
` 637
Item 10a continued
Motion seconded by Councilor Ginnings and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 10b
RESOLUTION NO. 98-2009
Resolution Authorizing The City Manager To Apply For and Accept A
Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery (TIGER)
Grant From The U.S. Department of Transportation Under the American
Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) Supplemental Discretionary
Grants For The Construction Of A New Passenger Terminal Facility At
The Wichita Falls Municipal Airport
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Resolution No. 98-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Smith and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 10c
RESOLUTION NO. 99-2009
Resolution Adopting Guidelines For Filming In Wichita Falls, Texas
Moved by Councilor Elmore that Resolution No. 99-2009 be passed.
Motion seconded by Councilor Smith and carried by the following vote.
Ayes: Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher, Councilors Barham, Smith, Ginnings and Elmore
Nays: None
Item 11 a
Mr. Matt Benoit, Assistant City Manager, gave a presentation on
suggestions for the re-use of retired Fire Station #8.
The following options were presented and discussed.
Option One - sell the property.
Option Two — lease the property
Councilor Ginnings asked if the Wood family put any restrictions on selling
or leasing the property because there is a memorial park to their family located by
the Fire Station. Mr. Benoit replied that there were no deed restrictions and we
would only be leasing or selling the Fire Station, its boundaries, and the
associated parking with it.
Mayor Pro Tern asked if the park area adjacent to the Fire Station would
be available to be included in the sale if sold, or is it restricted by the donor. It is a
significant piece of property, and he asked if there were any restrictions to selling
all of it. Mr. Benoit explained that if we are doing an election to sell the property
you can include in the election whatever elements of that entire tract that you
would chose to. He recommended the sale of the Fire Station and the associated
parking only.
638 '
Item 11 a continued
Option Three - use the facility for recreation programs.
Councilor Elmore asked what the amount of$312,688 reflected in this
option. Mr. Benoit explained the costs given in the presentation were high in all
areas because he figured renovation costs into all the options if renovation was
needed for the uses of the option chosen.
Option Four— use the facility to relocate two or three police units.
Option Five - use the facility for a branch library. There is an opportunity
for a branch library and recreation programs to co-exist. Given the size of
the station, putting both programs in the building might limit the full benefit
of programs.
Councilor Ginnings asked for clarification on the scope of the property.
Would the sale include or not include Wood Memorial Park. Mr. Benoit replied
that it would be best to have direction from Council on that.
City Manager clarified that what was presented to you did not include
Wood Memorial Park; it only includes the Fire Station and parking.
Councilor Ginnings asked if there is a need for police in that area to use
the facility for additional police units. Police Chief Bachman stated that it would
increase the presence of police there but it would be utilized for administrative
services, not be a sub station for the Police Department.
Councilor Ginnings commented that constituents on the southwest part of
town are interested in having a branch library in their area. The citizens have the
utilization of the Midwestern State University Library, but it would be great if we
could associate with Midwestern State University and have a branch library
together for the community.
Councilor Smith said he would also like to see a partnership agreement
with Midwestern concerning a branch library. He informed Council when it is
ready for discussion he has information for them to look at that he has received.
Mayor Pro Tern commented that we need to look at the value the property
would have on the market to us even including the park. As well as what the tax
value would be to our ailing budge. We need to look at the ongoing annual tax
revenues we could see versus owning it ourselves and the money goes the
opposite direction.
City Manager informed that if we look at $1 million in assessed evaluation
that you could gain from that property that would be a little less than $6000 a year
of taxes it would net us. That is probably on the high end when you factor in
exemptions and other things. With respect to the park that is there, it is a
strategic area because of its connection to Sikes Lake. Staff at this point would
not recommend including the park.
Item 11 b
Councilor Elmore received an email regarding the Sheppard Lawn
business on Burk Road. The owner passed away a couple of years ago and the
facility has declined terribly and something needs to be done with it.
Councilor Elmore received an email concerning the coffee shop or
hamburger place located on Missile Road. Several citizens inquired about getting
a drive in at that location. He commented that it may be viable for that business
but it is not part of zoning in that area for that particular type of business. If the
owners really want a drive in they need to come to the planning or zoning offices
to inquire about proper zoning in the area where the facility is located.
Councilor Elmore mentioned an incident occurred last Saturday at Old
Town Saloon involving local flight instructors from Sheppard Air Force Base and
some local people. He was disturbed because there were disparaging comments
made by the local people involved toward the instructors from the Sheppard, and
asked that it be pursued with due diligence. He has been in contact with
639
Item 11 b continued
Sheppard and they are concerned. The Council and the community have done a
marvelous job in developing a very close relationship with Sheppard Air Force
Base and 1 would love to see that maintained and increased if at all possible.
City Manager explained that we have a protocol and a system set up that
we communicate very closely with Air Force personnel. They should not have to
contact City Council and ask about an ongoing investigation or matters of that
nature. It is an ongoing investigation and I have checked with Police Department
staff and they are actively communicating with Sheppard on that investigation to
remedy that situation.
Councilor Elmore informed that on September 12th in the downtown and
surrounding areas in Wichita Falls there will be an event called the "Stroll and
Roll". The nine or so museums in the area are going to have a Museum Day.
Buses will be running from each of the facilities which include the Museum of
North Texas History, Wichita Falls Railroad Museum, Fire and Police Museum,
Kemp Center for the Arts, Kell House, Riverbend, and Callfield Museum. The
Wichita Falls Museum of Art at MSU will not be on the run with the buses but it
will be open. All the museums will be open from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. and free to the
public on this day.
Councilor Elmore inquired, for a friend, if anyone knew of any guitar
players around town that play funk, soul or slap. The type of music his friend is
inquiring about are from artists such as Bootsie Collins, George Clinton or Curtis
Mayfield. Sandy Montson with the Streams and Valleys has a son who is a very
talented bass player and he is looking for someone to play with.
Councilor Barham mentioned that he received the same email from the
Colonel of Sheppard Air Force Base about the incident at Old Town. He doesn't
think he was asking us to intervene he was just letting us know that this had
occurred and wanted us to be aware of the situation.
Councilor Barham complimented Mr. Jack Murphy on the playground
equipment and the elevated patio with the four picnic tables at Wood Memorial
Park; it all looks great. He asked what was going to happen to the restroom
facilities at the park that is locked up. Mr. Murphy responded that the plan in the
budget is to replace the roof. A contractor should be out there next week putting
the metal roof back on. The facility is functional and the fixtures have been
replaced from the old ceramic fixtures to all stainless steel fixtures.
Councilor Barham referred to the Code Red Policy and stated that the
Policy was well written by the Fire Department and it speaks well of what we need
to do with that technology.
Councilor Barham expressed his condolences to Councilor Roberts-Burns
for the loss of her sister and also to the H.B. Hodge family. Mr. Hodge was the
City Attorney for 27 years and was a very well liked and respected individual in
this community. It was a very sad day when he passed last week.
Councilor Ginnings also wanted to commemorate the memory of Mr.
Hodge. We did business together and he was a gentleman. I also would like to
send my condolences to Councilor Roberts-Burns for the loss of her sister.
Councilor Ginnings commented on the Mayor's rebuttal on behalf of Mr.
Matt Benoit in the letters to the editor. I want to commend and second that. One
thing that really disturbed me was the person that wrote the letter referred to Matt
as "Old Matt". I can talk to you about old.
Councilor Ginnings asked that Council seriously consider the use of traffic
cameras for the intersections that are capable of providing information that can be
enforced in court. When I go home and pull into the left turn lane at Taft and
Southwest Parkway I see so many cars that after the light has turned red continue
to zip through that intersection. I see so much of it that a terrible accident will
happen and I see the same cars on different days continue to go through the red
light. He asked for staff feedback on this matter. I have heard of companies
installing them but I would like for us to own and operate them.
Councilor Barham informed that the Traffic Safety Commission has looked
at that and it has been discussed in depth, and it is my understanding that it was
640
Item 11 b continued
moved over to the Police Department for their review. Mr. John Burrus, Director of
Aviation, Traffic and Transportation, informed that he believed it had been, but
there were legislative issues with that as well.
City Manager informed that staff was waiting to see what the legislative
session would do on that matter because so many bills were introduced that
would ban the use of those cameras. We did not feel that we should put a lot of
effort into that if the use of the cameras would be banned anyway. As you
mentioned, that did not pass, so they are still legal with certain parameters. Not
surprisingly, half the money would go to the state. Originally they were against
the idea until they come up with the idea of revenue sharing and then it was a
good program. The Traffic Safety Commission brought in a particular vendor and
had a demonstration done. It was their recommendation to the Council and staff
to pursue that. So if there is enough support amongst Council to advance that,
we will certainly look into it.
Councilor Ginnings commented on reading the legislature's graffiti
ordinance. I was really encouraged because there were provisions made for
assessing civil damages and property damages. However, I do not remember
anything about this procedure where we have to notify the property owner to
clean the graffiti up or we will do it free. I have tried to understand the logic
behind that so could you tell us briefly the rationale on that. He asked if there is
any legal basis for it.
City Attorney explained that under the City's ordinance the property owner
has to pay the price for the removal but only part of the price which is $50 if they
consent to having the graffiti voluntarily removed. What the legislature did was
mandate that we first offer to remove it for free. The legislature removed our
power to charge that $50 fee.
City Manager stated that Legal will present information concerning those
issues to Council. We would like to seek input from Council because it has budget
implications that we need to discuss. We need to sit down and figure out if we
want to continue enforcing the abatement of graffiti and how much it will cost the
City and if we want to put that in the budget or not.
Councilor Ginnings asked if this is something we could fight the legislature
on. City Attorney did not think so. It is in the power of the legislature to limit our
powers. As you know, a home rule city has only those powers to the extent of
that which the legislature has not specifically limited them to or cut them off of.
Quite often the legislature likes to enact state programs that they get to take the
credit for but we get to take the bill for.
Councilor Ginnings stated that he read somewhere in one of our founding
documents that all just powers are given by the consent of the governed. We are
the governed and I do not consent to this. This is just as bad as the discussion
we had at the last Council meeting where one of the state agencies, namely the
Water Quality Board, could not get the legislature to pass their budget so they just
increased their fees to us so that we could fund their budget. We are here trying
to take care of our own business and that gets dumped on us. As we have
determined since from our legislature, they did not know that this was happening.
Councilor Smith elaborated more on the Museum Day. He noted that the
Museum of North Texas History on Indiana Street and Riverbend Nature Center
which includes the Ruby Priddy Butterfly Conservatory will be part of the
transportation route on September 12. City shuttle buses will be provided and all
the Museums are open and free to the public on that day.
Councilor Smith mentioned that in the past week, he has heard news that
there is a H 1 N 1 Swine Flu Vaccine. He asked if it comes to pass and is ready by
the fall what will be done here as far as getting it out to the public. Mrs. Lou
Franklin, Health Director, responded that at this time we do not know. There will
be a H1 N1 Swine Flu Summit to be held in Austin August 101h. We will receive
more information at that time. It will depend on the amount of vaccine that we get
and every indication we receive will be done on a priority basis based on risk
categories. As we did in the past with shortages of the influenza vaccine it will be
based on priority. At this time we do not have much guidance from the state as to
how we are going to handle that.
641
Item 11 b continued
Councilor Smith asked if the vaccine will be distributed at the Health
Department or at the schools. Mrs. Franklin replied that every year we usually
have a mass vaccination clinic and we do that it serves as an exercise for a
preparedness grant and it allows us to prepare for these type of things where we
give a large number of vaccines in a short amount of time. Depending on the
quantity we get at that time that is probably the method we would use.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher asked the Boy Scout Troops to stand up so we
can applaud their attendance here. He thanked them for being here and hopes
they learned something today and were not bored completely to death.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher mentioned that this weekend United Regional will
have its official ribbon cutting ceremony for the new Bridwell Tower which will be a
tremendous asset to the community. I look forward to being a part of that this
weekend.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher mentioned that last Saturday he had the
opportunity to watch the Soap Box Derby. It was very interesting and so much
fun to watch. Those were the best looking cars and it reminded me of the pine
wood derby cars we used to build for scouts. These cars were a hundred times
bigger and you can actually sit in them. They had great paint jobs and fine
finishes; it was awesome. I sat at the finish line and watched them all come
across the line. It was a good event and well attended. He mentioned that it was
sponsored by the Downtown YMCA.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher asked Police Chief Bachman if he was aware of
the late night activity of folks riding four wheelers and disturbing the residents in
that live in the Ross Creek area. This is happening in the field just north of Ross
Creek, south of Langford and the Gregg Road intersection. There is some
undeveloped property in that area which is fenced off but there is a breach in the
fence. Chief Bachman replied that he had spoken with the property owner who is
a builder and explained to him what was going on. The owner said he would
repair the fence. Chief Bachman stated that any offenders caught in that area will
be prosecuted.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher asked if Fire Chief Foster would like to mention
anything on the ISO Rating audit that is coming up. We have not been rated
since 1993. The rating is 50% of your ability to fight fires, 40% is based on your
ability to deliver water, and 10% is based on something else. This has a big
impact on insurance rates on every homeowner and business in the community if
we can get our rating down. On a scale of one to ten we are rated three which is
good but we would like to go down to a two or one.
Fire Chief Foster informed that there are about seventy communities in the
United States that are rated 9s,.a one and two hundred that rate as a two. A three
means you are commercially rated which is a good rating; a ten is the worst rating
basically meaning you have no fire protection. It potentially affects your insurance
but ISO has a disclaimer that it is not a guarantee your insurance premiums will
be affected by your ISO rating. However, some insurance companies do not use
the ISO to set their premiums but some do. The ones that don't, their rates go
down because of competition. We have done a lot of improvements to the water
distribution system since our last rating, we have a new fire station, better
equipment, better manning, and a new dispatch center so we are hopeful that our
rating will improve in November when we get rated again.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher briefly discussed the topic of City pride and
mutual respect. Be neighborly in the upkeep of your property. We are looking at
a budget situation where property values have actually slipped a little. Councilor
Ginnings mentioned earlier that people are failing to take care of their property. If
you have a piece of property and you are getting ready to sell it you would like the
value of it to be as high as possible so you must maintain the upkeep of that
property. I have received so many calls recently of complaints from citizens
whose neighbors do not mow their grass or pick up tree limbs that fall onto their
property. I would like to encourage everyone to mow your grass and maintain the
upkeep of your properties. It does affect the City if everyone would just show a
little more pride and respect to your neighbors if you would just keep our
community clean.
642 '
Item 11 b continued
Councilor Ginnings requested that the City Attorney address Mrs. Sutton's
questions and challenges she made to Council, and that this be done in a memo
to Council. She questioned our legal authority to enforce these liens from several
fronts.
Councilor Elmore referred to Mrs. Sutton's statements and said he would
like an answer about the statute of limitations.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher mentioned that this Saturday at MPEC they are
having another wrestling event known as Falls Town Beat Down 2. It was well
attended last time and he asked Mr. Bob Sullivan, Director of MPEC, for an
update on the ticket sales. Mr. Sullivan replied that it is a boxing event not a
wrestling event. The first time at our facility it was very entertaining and we had a
very good crowd that attended. Ticket sales are not bad but we expect a good
walk up on Saturday.
Councilor Elmore referred to the retired Fire Station #8 presentation and
noted that Mr. Benoit had said after every option that it was 4B eligible. I have
looked at both 4A and 4B functions and 4A is limited to what they can fund but 413
can fund both 4A and 413 projects. 4B has a lot of infrastructure that we need
those funds for and at this time I would like for Council to consider utilizing 4A
funds for some of the projects because we have plenty of money in 4A that is just
sitting there. I would like input from Council and staff regarding this matter.
Mayor Pro Tern Hatcher stated that the last time this was brought up, 4A
had about $11 million unencumbered dollars and it was agreed that that was not
really too much money for 4A to need. The balance now is nearly double that and
at some point (probably now) it would be okay to slow the growth of 4A by cutting
the rate of contribution in half and letting 4B grow faster for the reasons Councilor
Elmore mentioned, and that it would take a public vote to shift the rate structure.
Councilor Smith agreed and asked for information for further discussion.
City Council adjourned 10:40 at a.m.
PASSED AND APPROVED this day of� 2009.
MAYOR
ATTEST:
dia Ozuna
ity Clerk
NOTICE OF MEETING
Regular Meeting Of The Mayor And City Council Of The City Of Wichita
Falls, Texas, To Be Held In The City Council Chambers Of The Memorial
Auditorium, 1300 Seventh Street, On Tuesday, July 21 , 2009 Beginning At
8:30 A.M.
City Council: Mayor Lanham Lyne, Councilors Glenn Barham, Michael
Smith, Dorothy Roberts-Burns, Rick Hatcher, Jim Ginnings,
and Charles Elmore.
1 . Call To Order
2. (a) Invocation: Reverend Kevin Tiaden, Pastor
St. Paul Lutheran Church
(b) Pledge Of Allegiance
3. Presentations —
Recognition of eAdvisor
The Philippines —
• Mayor of A ora Villamayor
• Gove p miro Ynares
• Natio I ecurithe President of the Philippines -
General Virtus Gill and his wife Lita Gil
4. Comments From The Public To Members Of The City Council
Concerning Items That Are Not On The City Council Agenda. People
Wishing To Address The Council Should Sign Up Prior To The Meeting
Commencing. A Five Minute Time Frame Will Be Adhered To For
Those Addressing Their Concerns.
5. Approval Of Minutes Of July 7, 2009 Regular Meeting Of The Mayor
And City Council.
CONSENT AGENDA
6. Resolution Awarding Bid For The City's Estimated Annual Supply Of
Meter Boxes And Lids To The Marta Company In an estimated amount
of $70,550.00 (Council Bill # 142)
City Council Agenda
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Page 2
REGULAR AGENDA
7. (a) Final Public Hearing To Receive Public Comments Concerning
The Proposed FY 2010 Action Plan Of The 2005-2009
Consolidated Plan To Allocate HOME Investment Partnership
Program (HOME) Funds in the amount of $555,120 and
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Funds In The
Amount Of $1 ,400,527 and Re-allocate $300,000 In FY 2009
CDBG Funds
(b) Resolution Approving The FY 2010 Action Plan Of The 2005-
2009 Consolidated Plan Of The City Of Wichita Falls To Allocate
HOME Investment Partnership Program (HOME) Funds In The
Amount Of $555,120 and Community Development Block Grant
(CDBG) Funds In The Amount Of $1,400,527 and Re-Allocate
$300,000 In FY 2009 CDBG Funds (Council Bill # 143)
8. (a) Public Hearing Concerning City's Application To Texas Parks &
Wildlife Department For A Matching Grant For Improvements In
The 80-Acre Wichita Bluff Open Space Site
(b) Resolution Designating Officials To Act On Behalf Of The City
For Local Park Grant Program Of The Texas Parks And Wildlife
Department; Certifying That The City's Matching Share Is
Readily Available; Dedicating The 80 Acre Wichita Bluff Open
Space Site For Permanent Public Park And Recreational Uses;
And Certifying That The Application Has Been Submitted To The
Appropriate Regional Council Of Governments For The Texas
Review And Comment System Review (Council Bill # 144)
9. Ordinances
(a) Ordinance Approving A Negotiated Resolution Between The
Atmos Cities Steering Committee And Atmos Energy Corp., Mid-
Tex Division Regarding The Company's Rate Review Mechanism
Filing In All Cities Exercising Original Jurisdiction (Council Bill #
145)
(b) Ordinance Amending Section 6.4 of Appendix A of the Wichita
Falls Code of Ordinances to Modify Regulation of Oil and Gas
Wells (Council Bill # 146)
City Council Agenda
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Page 3
(c) Ordinance Appropriating $9,433 To The Special Revenue Fund
For The Immunization Program Of The Wichita Falls-Wichita
County Public Health District (Council Bill # 147)
10. Resolutions
(a) Resolution Directing Closure Of A Railroad Crossing At Granger
Street, Subject to Burlington-Northern Santa Fe's Installation Of
A New Railroad Crossing At A Kell Boulevard Service Drive
Between Fairway And Barnett Roads (Council Bill # 148)
(b) Resolution Authorizing The City Manager To Apply For and
Accept A Transportation Investment Generating Economic
Recovery (TIGER) Grant From The U.S. Department of
Transportation Under the American Recovery and Reinvestment
Act (ARRA) Supplemental Discretionary Grants For The
Construction Of A New Passenger Terminal Facility At The
Wichita Falls Municipal Airport (Council Bill # 149)
(c) Resolution Adopting Guidelines For Filming In Wichita Falls,
Texas (Council Bill # 150)
11. Other Council Matters
(a) Staff Council Discussion
1 . Staff presentation of Suggested Uses of Former Fire
Station #8 On Miller Rd. (Matt Benoit)
(b) Discussion Of Items Of Concern To Members Of The City
Council.
12. Adjourn
Wheelchair or handicapped accessibility to the meeting is possible by using the handicapped
parking spaces and ramp located off the east parking lot on the Sixth Street entrance. Spanish
language interpreters, deaf interpreters, Braille copies or any other special needs will be provided to
any person requesting a special service with at least 24 hours notice. Please call the City Clerk's
Office at 761-7409. Wireless Listening System devices are available at the City Manager's reception
area or you may call 761-7404 for inquiries.
Every item on this agenda shall be considered a public hearing. Regardless of the agenda heading under which any item is listed, any
word or phrase of any item listed on this agenda shall be considered a subject for consideration for purposes of the Texas Open
Meetings Act and other relevant law, and City Council may deliberate and vote upon any such subject and resolutions related thereto.
Resolutions, ordinances, and other actions concerning any word, phrase, or other subject may be voted upon, regardless of any
language of limitation found in this agenda or any document referring to such action. Any penal ordinance, development regulation or
charter provision of the City of Wichita Falls or item which is funded by the current or next proposed City of Wichita Falls budget,
including,without limitation, any street,water pipe, sewer,drainage structure, department,employee, contract or real property interest
of the City of Wichita Falls, may be discussed and deliberated, and the subject is hereby defined as such without further notice. Any
item on this agenda may be discussed in executive session if authorized by Texas law regardless of whether any item is listed under
"Executive Sessions" of this agenda, regardless of any past or current practice of the City Council. Executive sessions described
generally hereunder may include consideration of any item otherwise listed on the agenda plus any subject specified in the executive
session notice. Executive sessions described generally hereunder are closed meetings, may include consideration of any item
City Council Agenda
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Page 4
otherwise listed on the agenda plus any subject specified in the executive session notice, and may include items under Texas
Government Code Sections 551.071,551.072,551.073,551.074,551.076, 551.084,and/or 551.087.
CERTIFICATION
I certify that the above notice of meeting was posted on the bulletin board at
Memorial Auditorium, Wichita Falls, Texas on the day of
, 2009 at o'clock (a.m.)(p.m.).
City Clerk