Landmark Commission Minutes - 11/29/2017MIR0TES
CA19 MARK uUmIZISS10
Movem5er zu, zui t
1QIEMBER5 PRESE19 i:
Michele Derr a Members
John Dickinson ■
Gnristy Caraharn ■
Jim ,uFinsun ■
JacRie Ceb�,v� ■
Anay Lee, Vhairperaun ■
Barney Brock ■ P&L Liaison
Karen Gagne, Planning Administrator a City 51arr
MattRaw Pru—*. Planner 11 ■
,iames'McKwAnie, SeniorAssistant Uty Attorney IN Legal Dept.
ABSENT:
Michael Smitn = ■ Council Liaison
Stack Fluod ■
Cindy Ramire` ■
I. Call r,-, order, and Introductions
VfSairpersum Andy Cue called the meeting to order at 12:01 p.m.
11. Review & Approval of MinUteS rrom ucmaur 14, z57 f.
Chairperson Cee called for review and approval or minat-. Crum the u%tv6er :z4, z01 l
CanamarR Commission meeting. Mr. Barney Brock made a 'motion to approve the
mirluteo. Mrs. Michele Derr seconded thie motioxi. The motion was taRen to a vote and
passed unanimombly.
ill. Application for Design Review - -t-05v i ilaen straut (west Aural Hvivhts) - Reyae*t
tw replace exiating Gft wood fence with s ft. cedar privacy renca (siavirr-ar ya-as).
Mr. Matthew Prouty statea the hai ive owner, 41r. Carlton- Huggies, was propoaimg to
replace tMu GAiOti1.q tense Wiffl an Stt. veaar privacy tense. Because the proposed fence
will be over r n. tall, it .,,ill ry ja re a permit Trurn Sanding Inspections. Re statea'the fence
would have a top cap, skirt, and concrete' Tooter.
Mr. Prouty stated staff viewed"the new fence as an improvement over tMe existing tense
and mum—mmcngca approval ut me aesigrrreview appliLation tor 1509 Tilden Street.
Mrs. Derr asked if the fence would go allove tMe eavea un Me garage. Mr. Prouty stated
the tense would match the height of the eaves on the garage. Mr..iim .iol mbUm aaKed It
appyuviriq the proposed 5 tt. tevice might carie any i5sues by setting a precedence Tor
LANDMARK rOMhd1SSIQd PArF 2 dovemher 29, 20' 7
nth®r gropartlac in the neighhnrhand that might be on a corner lot. Urs. Karen Gagne
etated that the naly addltinnal rectrh tlog placed on a rnrger lot would he to avnid erecting
anything in the sight visihility triangle. She eXplained that this reguirement was not
specific to historic districts, but was applied throughout the city.
Ur. Johgcng made 2 motion #n apprnua the rnnctructi_n of an tiff cedar ari" CV fence at
jr-nn Tilden Street, Mr, Rnrney Rrnck cacnnded the motion. The commiccing entad no
the Motion; motion passed unanimnusly.
IV. niscussion Item - Use of Non-Historical Materials (Vinyl Windowsl on secondary
alevationa not viaihie fro® the p_Llhlir' right-ofimaV.
Mr. erouty stated the discussion item wac in direct relating to an upcomigg Window
replacement project by per. Carlton Hughes of IBnQ Tilde® Street. ile ctatad that the U.R.
National Park Service had recently made some changes to their Design Standards, which
included rhaugec to laugungs related to Drimaot facades and secondant facades. He
stated the recnmmeodnting for windn_wreDInCemF'I]t for a prlG7aN facade '",®c cilli +n
reguire the maintaining of the original materials, and that n cerondnry facade, which is
not visible from the right-of-way, would he able to use a vinyl covered wood.de stated
that full ui®SCI windnuute --re still not allowed, but pointed out that several manufacturers
were producing viovl windowc that matrh tha hict®rir.I Dr-file of —cod windows.
Mr. Jim Johnson asked what would he reguired of a r:ontributing house that had replaced
the original windows with aluminum replacement windows. Mr. erouty stated that the
prefaranne would hA to go hark to +he _rigi®al wood, and that vinyl clad wood would be
anneptahle- on secondary facades, but full vinyl would etill ha r %ceidered unacceptable.
He stated it was Mr. Hughes' hope to glare vinyl noverad wood utigdniAm nn thea front
facade, and full vinyl on the secondary elevations. MrS. CnagnA stated vinyl cnvered wood
would he gue-tio®able for the nrimaot fagade. Chairperson Lee pointed out that they had
haan odviQed by the platl_nal c®rlr SW-ice on the Maskat Temnle n_roject to repair and
replar:e the existinq wood windows
V. 00-ar Business:
a) MonthIV rSpn_rt: naoOt cgu're Historic District. West Floral Heights Historic
®iatric$, MorningajeFe distAein niatrpnt
Mrs.- Michele Derr stated the p=ity of I ights earnde had gone very well. We. Gag®e
stated Downtown Development Inc. had 'Indinated there had hepg n record gumhar of
registered participants and believed the crowds to he a-record numher ac_ well. Mrs.
narr etatAd r)n%AintQ%sig VViChit' Ealls was going to be hosting a candle walk an
neremher 7jst, and Rackdoor Theater uiac rurrontly doi'n'g a Droduction of Sylvia,
which would run through necemher j stn _ _Rha etatc'd Wichita 2hcat®r w®- doing a
Droduction of A Christmas Story, whir'h would also run through necemhar j61h. Urs
r)®rr ateted the "hotel" sign at the Holt had been changed to read "dolt". Rhe -qfnted
the nigg had alcn he®n npwlV aai®ted and illuminated. _ Mrs. Christy Graham stated
the Idalf Piot war looking to nape® to the OWhlic on December 9". Mrs. Derr stated
Ganache To-Go was planned to npan necemher Rth
Ur. Jim Jn_hocn_n stated the Morningside neighborhood had met on the jst of Ontaher,
at which time it had heeg acearted th®t Dermits for work done in the neighhorhood
would require approval by tha I agdM=rk. r nmmiaei=g. We stated the neichborhood
CRROMIRRR UUmMI55IOi4 PMGE 3 RovemOr za, Ai r
y.
v.
would 53 doing luminaries on the 9th and -10" of December; with the bacR-up dates
being the -roth and 101.
Uhairpe"ii Lee stated vvlst Floral ReigFits had 100 mem6er3 participate in this
year's i urRey Trot 5k. Mr. DoRnson pointed out there had been an increase in criminal
mischiver in Morninybiae and asked it there Flan seen a similar trend in vve*t Floral
Heights. Mr. Cue Stated there had been an increase in petty 6ary1aries. Mrs. Ga-yne
asked if they could re quest of the Police Department an i„orea5e of patrols in the area.
IDirs. Derr stated increased patrals ovula be requested.
5) 13c3iyn Review Staff Authorized 41inur Alto ratio na/Repa 1 rs:
Mr. Prouty reported an the three staff authorized miner alterations/repairs:
1700 8ucnanern STruet - Heli/ave HVAC System - r nf,;ry Svc;
1307 Tilden SFreet xaplace Star age Building In-KOZI
7 Sag ri der, Streei Rep7ac:c Root vviln Same Marchand Cone, ucr;alI
c) Exteriur EmOullisfiments Not Consistent witrii Historical Character or
NeigROorMuod - Mr. Johnson asked if it was permitted to add major decorative
embeilishmentsthat are visible tern the public right-or-vvay and ,at ariyinal to the
fiame to contributing hUme5 in a Ristoric District. _ Mrs.- uayne btated that the purist
view would be not to create ralse Fii5toricibm._ She stated if the em67aili5hment was
arcMiteaurrally dpprpriate, it would 53 aomatFiing that could be considered, and
would be a goad question to ask of i Flu.
d) Articles & Perioaivala - Preservation - Fall 201 r - i he Meaalliun
oil. Now Business:
a) Mrs. va-yne stated the early registration deadline tar annual THC Preservation
Conference in Austin +ryas coming tap on Decemaer 1$1 and this deadline for hotel
Stipend applications Yras IQuvem5ur 2911.
15) AcAt Mty. - Mrs. Gagne stated that, duo to a cuntlict with the City Lzmncll rview
session, it had been requestea to have the date tar the January,_ [anamarR
Commission Pleetiny chianyed. Moving the meeting to Jannaq 3011 was agreed
upon.
V ill. Aai%-FaTn:
Meetiny adjourned at 1:00 pm
-- _.
Rnay Ie . amairperson Date -